The College Football Playoff (CFP) is facing a potential crisis as the sport considers expanding to a 24-team format. This proposal, championed by Big Ten commissioner Tony Petitti and supported by other powerbrokers, threatens to fundamentally alter the very essence of college football. The idea of 8-4 teams in the Playoff is particularly alarming, as it could lead to a significant shift in the sport's dynamics and values.
The author argues that the current 12-team playoff is ideal, ensuring that the regular season holds significance and that teams must perform consistently to reach the championship. Expanding to 24 teams would dilute the importance of the regular season, potentially leading to teams resting their stars in early games and focusing more on the postseason. This could result in a sport where teams with lower records can still compete for the national title, which goes against the traditional values of college football.
The expansion proposal is driven by self-preservation and job security, as the commissioners and administrators are responding to their own created crises. They argue that it will lead to tougher non-conference games and more meaningful late-season matchups, but the author believes these justifications are half-cocked. The expansion could also lead to a situation where coaches face increased pressure, as evidenced by the NFL's recent coaching changes.
The author also highlights the role of media and industry interests in the expansion debate. ESPN, the exclusive CFP rightsholder, has a vested interest in maintaining the current format, while Fox Sports CEO Eric Shanks supports the 24-team expansion. The potential loss of revenue from ending championship games is a significant concern, but the author questions the validity of the optimistic projections made by media consultants.
Ultimately, the decision lies with school presidents, who may not prioritize the playoff expansion. The author urges fans to voice their concerns to their school's administration, emphasizing the importance of preserving the soul of college football. The expansion proposal, akin to the comet in the movie 'Don't Look Up', is a threat that requires urgent attention and action from fans and administrators alike to prevent the sport from being destroyed.
